I dare you to host a Thanksgiving without pie. Jammed together in a tiny studio apartment in NYC circa 2019 or spaced 6 feet apart on a chilly patio in #2020, pie-less (read: joyless) tables does not a Thanksgiving make. Preferably, served toasty warm with an a la mode finish. So. What’s a girl to do when digging into said pie face first is no longer socially (or medically) acceptable!? Enter: The Hand Pie. Or the Muffin Tin Pie. Or Pie on a Stick. Or a p-icecream sandwich. Join us as we take you on a little journey through the magical halls of tiny, tiny pies and take a deep, mask covered breath knowing that Thanksgivings everywhere are not totally ruined.
Photo & Recipe: By Pie-Eyed Girl
HAND PIES
Hand pies can be made ultra simple with store bought pie crust and filling or as complex and layered as you’d like, with from-scratch ingredients.
Photo & Recipe: By Judy Kim
QUICKIE HOW-TO. At a very high level, you’ll need dough, filling and an egg wash. Same ingredients you need for standard pie. The great part though, is that you can tweak just about any traditional pie recipe to suit a hand pie by simply changing up cooking times.
Recipe & Photo: By Sally’s Baking Addiction
Start by determining your shape. You can freehand or use cookie cutters. The larger they are, the more time they will need to bake and the more filling they can support. Place your cut dough on a parchment lined baking sheet and make sure your base pieces are at least an inch apart. Add your filling, leaving a border around the edge to seal them.
From here, you can have fun decorating them using fondant cutters to pinch out leaves and florals or you can create a more traditional lattice shape, a braided top or a full coverage pie topper. If you top with a full piece of pastry, you’ll want to make sure to cut steam holes in the top to let the air escape.
Photo & Recipe: By Samantha Chiu
Next, simply seal the edges, add an egg wash and a sprinkle of turbinado sugar. Most hand pies will successfully bake up in 20-25 minutes at around 375 but it’s best to keep a watchful eye on them and pull them out when they seem evenly golden brown. If you are nervous, find a great recipe online and use their sizing and baking ratio as a guide.
OUR FAVORITE HAND PIE RECIPES: Mini Apple Hand Pies | Salted Caramel Apple Hand Pies | Vanilla Cardamom Pear Hand Pies | Pear & Cranberry Hand Pies
PIE BARS
A pie bar is the magical moment that happens when a pie marries a cookie. Usually with a shortbread or cookie base, the bars are layered with all of the traditional pie fixins.
Photo & Recipe: By The Recipe Critic
QUICK HOW-TO. Most recipes require a 9 x 13″ pan, fitted with parchment paper (which makes it really easy to lift out the bars so that you can get nice clean cuts). From there, you layer in your ingredients: cookie or shortbread dough, pie filling, nuts and crumbles on top. Bake like you would a blondie, let cool, then slice. For this little number, following a recipe is a must.
Photo & Recipe: By Choosing Chia
OUR FAVORITE PIE BAR RECIPES: Vegan Pumpkin Pie Bars | Pecan Pie Bars | Apple Caramel Cheesecake Bars | Sweet Potato Pie Bars
PIE ICE CREAM SANDWICHES
I made my first pie ice cream sandwich (or as we call them in our house…picecream sandies) a few years back during a shoot for the 4th of July. They were filled with berries and placed on either side of a generous scoop of vanilla ice cream. Since then, we’ve made these for nearly every holiday because well…PIE + ICECREAM. Duh.
Photo & Recipe: By The Delicious Life
QUICK HOW-TO. Making picecream sandies is very simple. Just whip up a batch of tiny hand pies and let them cool completely. You can freeze them if you have particularly delicate designs. Get your ice cream reaaaaaallly soft because the pie is fragile and you don’t want to ruin your sweet little pie when you are adding the ice cream. Now, there are two ways to construct the sandwich:
- Spread the ice cream out in a 9 x 12 dish and re-freeze it. You want it to be about 1-1.5″ high. Use a round cookie cutter, the same size as the one used on your pie, to cut out little ice cream rounds. Place in between your pies and freeze for an hour or so. While this yields the prettiest result, it’s also kind of a pain in the arse.
- Alternatively, let the ice cream soften for 10-15 minutes on the counter. Scoop the ice cream straight out of the bucket, in a nice round scoop, then flatten it a bit on a piece of parchment paper. Place the flattened disk between your pie and freeze.
We wrap ours with a piece of parchment paper to keep them nice and fresh!
Photo & Recipe: By Hot For Food
OUR FAVORITE ICE CREAM + PIE COMBOS.
Salted Caramel Apple Pie with Vanilla Bean || Bourbon Pecan Pie with Jeni’s Darkest Chocolate Ice Cream || Caramelized Pear Pie with Three Twins Land of Milk & Honey Ice Cream || Pumpkin Pie with Ben & Jerry’s Pumpkin Cheesecake Ice Cream || Sweet Potato Pie with Ben & Jerry’s Cinnamon Bun Ice Cream || Spiced Cranberry Pie with Ben & Jerry’s Urban Bourbon Ice Cream || Pecan Pie with Häagen-Dazs Butter Pecan Ice Cream || Blueberry Pie with Ben & Jerry’s Sweet Mascarpone Ice Cream || Apple Pie with McConnell’s Burnt Caramel Ice Cream || Custard Pie with Earl Gray & Butter Biscuit Ice Cream
PUSH-UP POP PIES!
Your guests will be charmed for days if you whip out a bowl filled with Push-Up Pop Pies!
Photo & Recipes: By What Should I Make For
QUICK HOW TO: All you need are the plastic push up pop containers, a pre-made pie and some whipped cream (or ice cream). Layer in scoops of pie with the cream and finish with a wooden fork + a ribbon tied around OR a pretty personalized label.
PIE ON A STICK
We are pretty sure that everything tastes better when eaten from a stick. Even pie. The bonus factor is that there are so many different ways to serve pie on a stick which means lots of “testing” that needs to happen in your mouth before you commit to a final recipe.
Photo & Recipe: By Montacometa
QUICK HOW TO: Using a silicone mold, layer pie crumble or pie crust, ice cream, filling and more crumble/crust. Repeat until you reach the top then insert a popsicle stick in and let set up in the freezer. Remove and devour.
Photo & Recipe: By Sarcastic Baker
QUICK HOW TO: Pie pops are actually really easy. You are just making tiny hand pies and tucking in a lollipop stick. The key is in putting the lollipop stick down first, before you add your filling (so pie dough, lollipop stick, filling, pie dough), then sealing the dough really tightly around the stick.
Photo & Recipe: By What Molly Made
For filling, choose anything from traditional pie flavors to more fun and whimsical versions like S’More or Chess Pie, just make sure that whatever is inside has already been cooked and softened (like fruits) as these won’t spend very long in the oven! Quick tip. Make sure to cook them well so that they aren’t flimsy when removed from the oven. Let them sit for a good hour before you attempt to transfer them.
Photo & Recipe: By Salt and Lavender
You can even make great use of your leftover pie (hahahaha, like there is ever leftover pie) by transforming them into breakfast pops layered with yogurt!?
SKILLET PIE
Perhaps my very favorite pick for a personal pie is…the miniature skillet tart. So simple, so gorgeous, so perfect with a scoop of ice cream melting into every nook and cranny.
Photo & Recipe: by Sprinkle Bakes
We found these great 3.5″ (TINY!) skillets that you can buy in a pack of four which would make for absolutely darling mini pies. But if you want a little bit bigger, look for something in a 5-6″ range. To measure out your dough, you can flip the skillet over and trace the outline of the skillet. A little larger than you think is always a good bet. Once you have your rounds, just fit them inside the skillets, letting the excess dough hang over the side. Then fill ‘er up! Fold the excess dough over the top, add small pads of butter to the filling, brush the dough with an egg wash, then sprinkle with big, beautiful turbinado sugar. Depending on the size, you’ll bake for around half an hour. If you are worried about baking time, use one of the recipes below!
Photo & Recipe: by Lauren Conrad
OUR FAVORITE SKILLET PIE RECIPES: Easiest Ever Rustic Apple Tart | Individual Skillet Pecan Pie | Mini Pumpkin Pie Skillets
PIES & JARS … JAR PIES.
The mason jar just might be the best thing that has ever happened to desserts. Whether you bake them inside the jar and hand them out with a pretty spoon and a dollop of vanilla ice cream OR you use the lids as miniature pie tins, you can really let your pie-magination run wild with these babies.
Photo & Recipe: By Giggles Galore
Pies in a Mason Jar Lid. That is actually a thing. And we are here for it. Use your mason jar lid just as you would a larger pie, but cut the dough just larger than the lid and tuck inside so that the sides of the dough have a bit of a lip around the inside of the lid. Add your fillings, topper (more pie crust, egg wash + a sprinkle of sugar OR a crumble of some kind) and bake. Usually around 12-15 minutes at 375. You can serve these with ice cream or whipped cream on top, in the lid or popped out of the lid or just wrap them in 4 x 6″ clear bags and let the guests open themselves!
Photo by: Ethan Calabrese as seen on Delish.com
Pies in a Mason Jar. A pie in a mason jar can take on many forms. It can be cooked ahead of time, then layered in the jar. It can be built with dough and fillings and baked just as you would a pie. It can be tiny with just a pie topper and no dough inside or it can be large and overflowing with baked goodness.
For a slam dunk every time, we suggest either the layering of finished pie ingredients OR miniature pie topped jars. To make the minis, fill your jars nearly to the top with filling. Add a bit of egg wash to the rim of the jar and place your topper on – cut to just slightly larger than the jar, making sure there are steam holes. Cover with egg wash and a sprinkle of sugar and bake for 12-15 minutes.
MINIATURE PIES
Mini pies are essentially hand pies but they are formed in a small pie or muffin tin to retain their shape. What I love most about doing a series of mini pies is that you can vary the fillings and guests can get a taste of everything. Plus, the smaller they are, the more you can eat!
Photo & Recipe: By The Kitchen McCabe
FAVORITE MINI PIES + SUPPLIES. To create beautiful miniature pies, all you need are the right tools and supplies + a stellar recipe. Muffin Tins, Miniature Tart Pan, Mini Pie Tins all work beautifully. But so do brownie pans, popover pans, and mini loaf pans. There are SO many options for making tiny pies, just open your cabinet and see what you have!
Photo & Recipe: By Julie Jones
QUICK HOW-TO. Making mini pies is fairly straight forward if you set yourself up right from the beginning. Make sure to prepare your pan, treating every cavity like you would its own individual pie dish. Butter or grease them, line them with parchment paper, whatever your go-to method for prepping muffins is will work here.
Photo & Recipe: By Julie Jones
Because you are working with tiny bits of dough and likely warm hands, your dough might get soft quickly. Thus, you may need to refrigerate as you go. As the dough starts to soften, pop it back in the fridge to firm back up.
Photo & Recipe: By Inspired Chick
These little pies cook quickly, so make sure your fillings are pre-cooked or softened. Once you have your cups filled, and your tops topped, pop them into the fridge for an hour or the freezer for 10-15 minutes. They will hold their shape much better if they go into the oven cold. Most mini pies – depending on size – will cook in 20-30 minutes. When you take them out, let them sit in the pan for 10 minutes to set up a bit more
Photo & Recipe: By Lauren Conrad
OUR FAVORITE MUFFIN TIN & MINI PIE RECIPES (click links under photos for more!): Miniature Apple Pies | Miniature Pecan Pies | Miniature Pumpkin Pies | Miniature Cranberry Meringue Pies | Miniature Lemon Meringue Pies | Milk Chocolate Cream Pies |
PACKAGING
While you can certainly just have these little mini delights out for your guests to see, if you really want to button up those Covid practices, consider packaging them before you serve!
Photo by Heather Waraksa
Mini Pie Boxes. There are so many cute ones out there to choose from. We are partial to the ones with a peek-a-boo window at the top like these or these (tied with a pretty butcher’s twine + a disposable spork) but there are a million options out there. Just make sure you check your the size of your finished pie before buying! Oh and if you aren’t doing mini pies…how cute are THESE little individual pie boxes that we made a while back!?
Photo & Design: By Jenny Cookies
While Clear Bags and Boxes. A simple and inexpensive way to package up your pies. You can add a piece of scrapbooking card stock as well so that the pies have a pretty backdrop OR add a handwritten note of thanks that peeks through. If using a box, you can fill with sprinkles or paper shred to give your pie a little nest to sit upon.
Photo: By Rachel May as seen on Martha Stewart
A Finishing Touch... Include a gilded disposable fork or a bamboo spoon. Print your own labels or use a pretty stamp directly on the label paper to seal up your bag or box. Tie a chic ribbon around them that matches your color palette. You can really go all out with these and make them something so special, your guests hardly realize that it’s all in the name of safety.
Join The Conversation
favorite (0) share share (0) pin (0)